Shelby County, Indiana

County Distress Index: Elevated · 55.1 | 45,231 people · 24th most distressed in Indiana
American Default Research

Behind on your mortgage or facing eviction? Take a 2-minute assessment to see your options.

Shelby County, IN registers elevated household financial distress with a score of 55.1 — 1264th nationally out of 3144 counties. The primary driver is Legal Distress, where bankruptcy filing rates are well above the national average. Within Indiana, it ranks 24th of 92 counties. Among its 6 neighboring counties, 5 show less distress.

The Numbers Behind the Score

The CDI measures five statistically derived factors of household financial distress, PCA-weighted. Shelby County's primary driver is Legal Distress at 85.2 — worse than roughly 85% of U.S. counties.

Legal Distress Primary driver 85.2
Bankruptcy Filing Rate 85
Economic Vitality 68.9
Wage-to-Rent Ratio 83
Rent-to-Income Ratio 79
Business Formation Rate 42
House Price Change (YoY) 18
Consumer Credit Distress 58.5
Debt in Collections 59
Medical Debt 85
Auto Loan Delinquency 45
Credit Card Delinquency 65
Uninsured Rate 31
Subprime Credit Population 58
Housing Cost Burden 46.5
Rent-Burdened (30%+) 42
Severely Rent-Burdened (50%+) 52
Mortgage-Burdened (30%+) 34
Homeownership Rate 53
Structural Poverty 31.6
Unemployment Rate 8
Poverty Rate 31
Income vs. State Median 33
Child Poverty Rate 24
Disability Rate 45
Transfer Income Dependency 40

Scores are percentile-based: 50 = national median, higher = more distressed.

Neighbors and Peers

Neighboring Counties

CountyScoreZonevs. Shelby County
Shelby County, IN 55.1 Elevated —
Marion County, IN 73.0 Serious +17.9
Rush County, IN 52.0 Elevated -3.1
Bartholomew County, IN 48.9 Normal -6.3
Decatur County, IN 48.5 Normal -6.6
Johnson County, IN 46.7 Normal -8.4
Hancock County, IN 37.8 Normal -17.3

Population Peers

CountyScoreZonevs. Shelby County
White County, GA 55.1 Elevated -0.0
Benton County, TN 55.1 Elevated +0.0
Gilchrist County, FL 55.1 Elevated +0.0
Monroe County, GA 55.2 Elevated +0.0
Franklin County, AR 55.0 Elevated -0.1

Download Data

Export all distress indicators for Shelby County as a CSV file.

Find Help in Shelby County

Find an Attorney

Indiana State Bar Association — Lawyer Referral Service offers a lawyer referral service for bankruptcy, foreclosure defense, and consumer rights.

Indiana State Bar Association — Lawyer Referral Service 317-639-5465

Free Legal Aid

Legal aid organizations serving Shelby County residents at no cost.

Indiana Legal Services (ILS) 317-631-9410 (Indianapolis); 1-888-529-4917 (statewide hotline)
Legal Aid Society of Tippecanoe County 765-742-1050
Neighborhood Christian Legal Clinic 317-429-4131

American Default Research does not endorse, rate, or rank any provider. Verify attorney credentials with your state bar.

Need legal help? Find a foreclosure defense attorney in Indiana →

Continue Reading

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What is the distress score for Shelby County, Indiana?

    Shelby County has a County Distress Index score of 55.1 out of 100, placing it in the Elevated zone. It ranks 1,264th nationally out of 3,144 counties and 24th in Indiana out of 92 counties.

  • What drives financial distress in Shelby County?

    The primary driver of distress in Shelby County is Legal Distress, where the county scores 85.2 out of 100. This domain is measured by indicators including Bankruptcy Filing Rate.

  • How does Shelby County compare to neighboring counties?

    Shelby County (55.1) can be compared to its 6 neighboring counties: Marion County, IN (73.0); Rush County, IN (52.0); Bartholomew County, IN (48.9).

  • How is the County Distress Index calculated?

    The County Distress Index uses PCA-weighted percentile scoring across five statistically derived factors: Consumer Credit Distress (47.5%), Housing Cost Burden (22.3%), Structural Poverty (13.6%), Economic Vitality (9.2%), and Legal Distress (7.4%). Each county's indicators are ranked against all 3,144 U.S. counties. A score of 50 means the county is at the national median; higher scores indicate greater distress.

  • How often is the CDI updated?

    Annually, aligned to Census American Community Survey and Urban Institute Debt in America release windows — the slowest-moving source inputs. Between annual refreshes, faster-cadence indicators (BLS unemployment, QCEW wages) may drive light mid-year updates if a specific component moves meaningfully. Current data compiled April 14, 2026; next full refresh early 2027.

  • What does the Elevated zone mean?

    The CDI divides counties into five zones: Healthy (below 46), Normal (46–55), Elevated (55–71), Serious (71–86), and Crisis (86 and above). Shelby County's score of 55.1 sits in the Elevated zone (55–71).

  • What data sources power Shelby County's CDI score?

    Shelby County's CDI score draws on Urban Institute Debt in America (Equifax credit-bureau panel), U.S. Census Bureau (American Community Survey 5-year, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates), Bureau of Labor Statistics (LAUS, QCEW), U.S. Courts Administrative Office (F-5A bankruptcy filings), and HUD Fair Market Rents. Every number on this page traces to one of these public sources.

  • What is the population of Shelby County?

    Shelby County, Indiana has a population of approximately 45,231 (2023 Census estimate), classified as a small county.